Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition
Accounting · Lesson

Explain a ratio's limitation instead of declaring a company good or bad

A ratio feels like an answer, so it is easy to write a verdict when the question wanted a reasoned judgement.

On this page
  1. Why is a limitation more useful than a verdict?
  2. Worked example
  3. The mistake to watch for
  4. Check yourself
  5. Where this leads next

A ratio is evidence, not a verdict. A strong conclusion uses this shape: what the ratio suggests, what it cannot show, and what additional information would help. It avoids words like “good” and “bad” unless the data supports them.

This final lesson of ratios and interpretation builds on comparing firms with context.

Why is a limitation more useful than a verdict?

Accounting figures are summaries. They depend on choices such as how inventory is valued and when expenses are recognised. A statement of financial position is a snapshot of one day, which may not represent the rest of the year.

When you name a relevant limit, you show the examiner that you understand what the ratio is made from.

Worked example

Rumah Kasih Bakery, a fictional business, shows these figures at 31 December.

Current assetsRMCurrent liabilitiesRM
Inventory35,000Trade payables20,000
Trade receivables10,000
Cash5,000
Total50,000Total20,000

Step 1, calculate. Current ratio = 50,000 ÷ 20,000 = 2.5 : 1. Liquid ratio = (50,000 − 35,000) ÷ 20,000 = 15,000 ÷ 20,000 = 0.75 : 1.

Step 2, say what it suggests. Current assets are two and a half times current liabilities. But inventory is 70% of current assets (35,000 ÷ 50,000), and the liquid ratio is below 1.

Step 3, name relevant limits. The ratios use one date only. If the bakery stocks up before a festive season, December figures may be unusual. Inventory is also valued by the business, and unsold goods may need selling at a lower price.

Step 4, name extra information. Inventory turnover, an ageing of receivables and the cash forecast for the next quarter would show whether the debts can be paid on time.

Step 5, write the conclusion. “The current ratio of 2.5 : 1 suggests current assets cover current liabilities, but with a liquid ratio of 0.75 : 1 the business relies on selling inventory. This is a year-end snapshot and seasonal stocking may affect it. We need the cash forecast and inventory turnover before judging liquidity.”

The mistake to watch for

Mistaken answer: “The current ratio is 2.5 : 1, which is above 2 : 1, so the bakery is in a good position.”

The student applied a rule of thumb as if it were a verdict, and did not look at what the current assets contain.

The correction is to use the structure above. A target ratio is a starting point for questions, not proof of health. The same applies the other way: a low ratio does not prove a business will fail.

Check yourself

1. Rewrite this sentence so it is balanced: “A profit margin of 12% shows the business is well run.”

Show answer

Example: “A profit margin of 12% suggests the business keeps 12 sen of profit from each RM1 of sales. It does not show how this compares with last year or with similar businesses, so the trend and the type of business are needed before judging how well it is run.”

2. Revenue RM90,000 and profit RM9,000. Find the profit margin and give one limitation.

Show answer

Profit margin = 9,000 ÷ 90,000 = 10%. One limitation: it covers one year only, so it cannot show whether profit is improving or whether the year included unusual items.

3. Why might a year-end liquid ratio mislead a business that trades heavily at one time of the year?

Show answer

Receivables, inventory and payables on the year-end date may be much higher or lower than at other times of the year. The ratio shows that single date, not the usual level.

Where this leads next

Try the ratios and interpretation practice set to put all five lessons together. The ratios with interpretation limits tool helps you practise structuring a conclusion, and the percentage-base explorer supports the arithmetic.

If conclusions are where you lose most marks, a teacher in online one-to-one Accounting tuition can work through your own answers with you.

Questions people ask

Why is 'the company is good' a weak conclusion?

It states a verdict that a single ratio cannot support. Ratios use figures from one date or one year, built from choices such as inventory valuation. A strong conclusion says what the ratio suggests, what it does not show, and what extra information would help.

What limitations can I mention for ratios?

Ratios use historical figures, a statement of financial position shows one date only, accounting policies can differ, seasonal trade can distort year-end figures, and ratios ignore non-financial factors. Choose limitations that fit the case in the question, not a general list.

How long should a ratio conclusion be?

Two to four sentences is usually enough. State what the ratio shows, give one or two relevant limits tied to the case, and name one piece of extra information. Short and specific is better than long and general.

Updated:

Your next step

If your conclusions tend to be one-line verdicts, a one-to-one teacher can rewrite a few of your own answers with you until the balanced structure becomes automatic.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80.

Tuition is arranged with a parent or guardian. Send them this page on WhatsApp and they can enquire for you.

Parents: enquire here

  • 9,000+ students helped through our service
  • 9+ years helping IGCSE students